How to Make Cookies in a Jar For a Gift

cookies in a jar hero shot

Rita Shehan

These cookie mixes in mason jars will make fun and unique gifts for all of your friends. We made these cookie mixes, complete with recipe gift tag, and they were loved by everyone on our gift list. We know everyone on your gift list will like them too. Make sure to add your own special touches and creativity when you make your cookie mix jars.

Follow the steps below to make your cookies in a jar. Start by gathering the basic supplies you will need. Then pick a recipe and gather together those ingredients. Finally, you can fill and decorate the jar. Don't forget to print out a recipe gift card to give along with the jar.

supplies needed for cookies in a jar
Rita Shehan

Gathering Supplies

Start by gathering these essential supplies. You will use the same basic supplies no matter what cookie recipe you choose.

  • Quart size canning jars with lids
  • Decorative holiday ornament
  • Pretty holiday themed fabric *Optional
  • Ribbon
  • Glue
  • Paper for tag
  • Recipe tag template
  • Recipe and Required Ingredients (below)
  • Hole punch

Filling the Jar

Follow these simple instructions when you are ready to start filling your jars with the cookie ingredients.

cookie mix in a jar
Rita Shehan
  1. Thoroughly wash and dry the jars and lids.
  2. Pick a recipe from below and gather your ingredients.
  3. Use the instructions and tips from the recipe you choose and fill the jar.
  4. Layer each dry ingredient listed in the recipe into the mason jar. It helps to use a wooden spoon when firmly patting down each layer.

Choose a Recipe and Printable Tag

Browse through the recipes below and choose your favorite to try or you can try them all.

Make a printable tag to attach to your cookie jar craft in Microsoft Word or whatever software you are comfortable using. Printable tags are also available on many websites for free download.

Decorating the Jar

Use your imagination and these suggestions to decorate your jars. There is no right or wrong way when it comes to adding embellishments to your cookie jar craft.

bow around cookie jar mix
Rita Shehan

Ribbon: Cut an approximate 2-foot piece of ribbon. We used two pieces of red glitter colored ribbon. The first ribbon was wrapped around the neck of the jar, and then a bit of glue was applied to hold it in place. Then we tied a bow out of the ribbon, trimmed the tails and attached to the jar with a bit of glue on the back center of the bow

ribbon and ornament around decorative jar
Rita Shehan

Fabric or Decorative Ornament: Wrap about two feet of silver metallic cord around the neck of the jar and tie into a knot. Run the cord through the top of the ornament and tie another knot.

Another option is to insert a circle of fabric under the lid of the jar. Cut a circle out of the fabric that is 6- to 8-inches across. We traced around the top of a bowl. Place the round section of the jar's lid on the jar and center the fabric on that. Screw the other part of the lid in place to hold the fabric. Fluff out the fabric where it comes out from under the lid.

cookie jar with ornament and recipe card
Rita Shehan

Recipe: Print out your choice of the printable recipe card/gift tag with the recipe you chose. Trim carefully around the recipe and graphic. Put a small piece of scotch tape on the upper right-hand section of the 'Printable Gift Tag' recipe (right behind the top edge of the graphic). This reinforcement is to give it a little extra strength. Use a hole puncher and make a small hole in the taped corner. Run the metallic cord through the hole and tie another knot.

Your thrifty and beautiful DIY Christmas cookie jar is now finished. Give these jars to your friends and watch their faces light up when they receive this practical gift.