Best Knitting Subscription Boxes

Needles, Notions, and Instructions Delivered to Your Door

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Best Knitting Subscription Boxes

The Spruce / Design by Amelia Manley

Keep your knitting needles in motion with a regular delivery of yarn and a project pattern by signing up for a knitting subscription box. This service provides beginner and more advanced knitters the ability to receive instructions for knitting items like hats, socks, and afghans. The included yarn is the right weight for the project, eliminating guesswork of the best type to buy for that Bolin shawl you’ve been eyeing to try. Many subscription boxes offer an option to receive needles and notions, too.

The best knitting subscription boxes include small-batch yarn that you won’t typically find at a big box craft store. And aside from the tools and materials you’ll find inside your knitting box, some companies also offer online video tutorials to help you through more complex aspects of the project. Read on for the best knitting subscription boxes.

Best Knitting Subscription Boxes of 2021

Best Overall: PostStitch

PostStitch

PostStitch

Why We Chose It: This monthly knitting subscription box is big on surprises, with a new project, skeins of yarn, and knitting needles and notions inside each delivery.

Pros
  • Free shipping in the U.S.

  • Option to skip a box

  • Can select which yarn colors to avoid

Cons
  • No preview of project and box contents

  • Lacks video tutorials for each project

Keep your knitting needles in motion with a monthly delivery from PostStitch. This knitting subscription service delivers a new project pattern and the necessary yarn to complete it. If you opt for the big KnitStitch box at $60 per month, you’ll also receive needles and notions to suit the project. However, if you have a well-rounded set of knitting needles on hand or would prefer to skip the notions, you can subscribe to more minimal KnitStitch boxes that range from $40 to $50 a month. 

PostStitch stands out for also offering a sock-specific knitting subscription box. If you’re hooked on handmade socks, the SockStitch box will keep you busy with a new pattern and a skein or two of sock-weight yarn each month.

Best for All Skill Levels: Knit-Wise

Knit-Wise

Knit-Wise

Why We Chose It: Knit-Wise recognizes that knitting skill sets vary and offers knitting subscriptions for beginners, along with a subscription option for intermediate or advanced knitters. Learners will appreciate the simple, approachable projects of the Beginner box before moving up to more advanced project patterns.

Pros
  • Pick a subscription to match your skill level

  • Projects are designed to be completed in a month

Cons
  • No choice of colorways for yarn received

  • Project guidance is limited; no videos available

Newbie knitters and experienced casters alike will benefit from the subscription boxes offered by Knit-Wise. Choose from Beginner or Intermediate/Advanced subscription options based on your skillset.

For knitters just starting out (or those in need of a serious skills refresh), the Beginner box includes easy projects that won’t intimidate you in terms of skill or time to complete. Projects might include a simple hat or a cozy coaster.

The Intermediate/Advanced knitting subscription box is best for those who already have a basic grasp of knitting techniques. This box focuses on unique and useful projects—like an eye mask and neck pillow cover for travel.

Both boxes are a great value, starting at just $29 a month with the ability to cancel any time. Aside from the project pattern and necessary yarn, the subscription also includes the needles and notions you’ll need to knit up your project in no time. And while Knit-Wise doesn’t offer project-specific video tutorials each month, the site does have a resource of free video lessons for basic skills that beginners will find helpful.

Best With Video Tutorials: Alpaca Direct – Kelly’s Knit Club

Alpaca Direct

Alpaca Direct

Why We Chose It: Every month, receive a new knitting pattern and yarn to complete it—along with access to a series of videos demonstrating the techniques you’ll need to master for each project.

Pros
  • Videos are a great tool for visual learners

  • Members-only group has extra benefits

Cons
  • No option to preview boxes or choose colorways

Receive more than just a project pattern and yarn when you subscribe to Kelly’s Knit Club from Alpaca Direct. This knitting subscription box goes the extra mile to help subscribers complete each project by creating five to 10 video tutorials, detailing important steps or tricky spots in the design of the month. These videos are available on an exclusive members-only page of the website and the club's mobile app.

Kelly’s Knit Club is a simple way to keep up with a new knitting project, and it’s recommended for beginner to intermediate skill sets. Subscription boxes start at $34.95, with an additional charge of $4.99 for shipping. You can pause or cancel any time if you fall behind on your needlework or need to take a break.

Best Quarterly: Knit 1 Chicago Subscription Box

Knit 1

Knit 1

Why We Chose It: Shipping four times each year, every knitting box from Knit 1 Chicago features a unique project pattern from a different designer.

Pros
  • Unique projects from rotating designers

  • Includes a virtual class

  • Select color family preferences

Cons
  • One project for all skillsets

Keep a fresh rotation of projects all year long with a quarterly knitting subscription from Knit 1 Chicago. This brick-and-mortar retailer partners with makers to create unique knitting projects for January, April, July, and October deliveries.

Inside every box, you’ll receive the project pattern along the yarn necessary to complete your quarterly knitting project. Needles and notions are included too, making this the complete package for knitters in need of inspiration. It’s worth mentioning that subscribers will also receive exclusive access to at least one free virtual class each quarter. Test the waters with a single box, or sign up for the full year for $320, and you’ll receive a bonus notions box during the course of the year.

Best for Afghans: Annie’s Kit Clubs

Annie’s Kit Clubs

Annie’s Kit Clubs

Why We Chose It: Knit a blanket block-by-block or row-by-row with a monthly delivery that includes patterns, yarn, and detailed instructions from Annie’s Kit Clubs. This approach makes it easy for experienced and novice knitters alike to take on a long-term afghan knitting project.

Pros
  • Multiple color options for your project

  • Video tutorials provide in-depth instruction

Cons
  • Project timeline is 10 or 11 months

A handknit blanket makes a fantastic keepsake or gift, but also is a practical project to cozy up with on the couch. However, getting started—and staying motivated—with such a large project can be a challenge. Annie’s Kit Clubs offers a knitting subscription box for afghans to help you succeed at making a blanket while enjoying the process.

Choose between the block-of-the-month club or the knit striped afghan club. With either knitting subscription, you’ll receive the patterns, yarn, and instructions to add three additional blocks or rows to your blank each month. Techniques start simple and advance as the months go on, helping you learn new skills while adding variety to your afghan.

While some knitting subscriptions for blankets offer a single color theme, both the striped and block afghan clubs include three different color options for subscribers to choose from. Both afghan knitting subscriptions cost $19.99 per month, with the option to cancel at any time. But remember that the blanket takes 10 or 11 months to complete, so if you opt-out early, you’ll have an unfinished project on your hands. For this reason, most people will want to keep on track with this monthly subscription until the project is complete.

Best Value: Yarn Yay

Yarn Yay

Yarn Yay

Why We Chose It: Receive a monthly project pattern plus curated yarn and unique notions with each delivery of this knitting subscription box. As an added benefit, members receive access to Yarn Yay’s exclusive Facebook group, where you’ll find video tutorials and events.

Pros
  • Projects include variations for knitting and crocheting

  • Video tutorials are available in the Facebook group

  • Receive artisan yarn

Cons
  • No option to choose colorways

  • Some projects may be advanced for beginning knitters

Yarn Yay offers a monthly knitting subscription that checks off all boxes for value. It includes an exclusive project pattern for knitters (and crocheters, too), artisanal, hand-dyed yarn in the right weight to complete the design, and notions to fit the theme of the box. As a sample, a recent project box featured a Parisian theme, complete with project directions for a stylish beret made of softly hued baby alpaca and silk yarn. The box included a poodle stitch counter and Eiffel tower scissors for more stylish snipping.

This knitting subscription box adds value with a full lineup of monthly Facebook events that are exclusive to members. Log on to find video tutorials, live Q&A sessions, and subscriber meet-ups. Knitting boxes start at $35 a month and shipping is free within the U.S. You can pause or cancel anytime.

Final Verdict

PostStitch is our top recommendation for a knitting subscription since it offers three different tiers of KnitStitch boxes to fit your needs. The project patterns vary by month and you can discover new designs and yarns as you create each piece. However, if you’re a visual learner or just starting out with knitting, you might consider a knitting subscription box with video tutorials—like Kelly’s Knit Club from Alpaca Direct.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is a Knitting Subscription Box?

A knitting subscription box typically includes two primary components—a project pattern and the yarn necessary to complete the project. Needles for the project or additional notions (such as stitch counters, scissors, etc.) may be included depending on the box you choose.

Why Order a Knitting Subscription Box?

While it may seem simple to order yarn online and scope out new knitting projects, the advantage of a knitting subscription box is that all the legwork is done for you. Instead of losing your crafting time to research and buying, you’ll receive a box with everything you need to create a new knitting project.

How Much Do Knitting Subscription Boxes Cost?

The cost of a knitting subscription box varies, depending on the scope of the project, the yarn included with the box, and whether or not you’ll also receive needles and notions. On average, knitting boxes cost between $30 and $50 per month. Take note that some companies charge for shipping, while others include it with the cost of the subscription.

How We Chose the Best Knitting Subscription Boxes

We researched some of the most popular knitting boxes on the market, along with lesser-known subscription boxes from brick-and-mortar yarn stores. Knitting subscriptions were evaluated on price point, yarn quality, project variety, and ability to customize the box (colorway choices, option to include or exclude needles and notions, etc.). In some cases, there were lengthy waitlists for new members of a knitting subscription box, so we omitted these companies from our list.

Continue to 5 of 6 below.