Best Coin Collection Appraisal Services

Heritage Auction Coins is our top pick

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Photo composite of hand placing coin in collectors' portfolio beside two antique coins

The Spruce / Designed by Amelia Manley

Whether you’ve inherited an old coin collection or have been putting together a set of your own, appraising your coins with an expert is always a good idea. Not only will it help you get an accurate valuation, but many times, it is needed to insure your collection.

The best coin collection appraisal services are those that offer both free and professional appraisals, have certified experts on staff, and have experience handling all types of coins. A select few not only appraise but auction off and buy coins from its customers. Here, we've collected the best coin collection appraisers.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Heritage Auctions Coins

Heritage Auctions

Heritage Auctions

Why We Chose It: Heritage Auctions Coins is one of the top online auction sites in the world, with currency sales topping $4 billion since its inception. Heritage has numismatic experts on staff for professional appraisal services, as well as free appraisals for auction items.

Pros
  • Free appraisals for auction items

  • On-staff numismatic experts

  • Professional appraisals available

  • Experience with U.S., world, and rare coins

Cons
  • Free appraisal is for auction sale items only

  • Professional appraisals require direct contact

Heritage Auctions was founded in 1976 and has become one of the largest auction houses in the United States. Its coin auction site has hosted and sold some of the most prestigious coin collections in the world, and the company keeps a staff of numismatic experts who can help identify, certify, and appraise your coins.

Heritage offers two appraisal services:

  • Free appraisal: This complimentary appraisal service is strictly for those looking to use Heritage auction services to sell their coins or collection. Users can submit their collection details online and upload pictures.
  • Professional appraisal: Heritage has a team of numismatic experts, many with ISA (International Society of Appraisers) and ASA (American Society of Appraisers) certification. They offer paid appraisal services that are valid for legal or insurance purposes.

Heritage also offers auction services, as well as direct purchasing of appraised items. This gives users the ability to not only value their coins but sell them all in one place.

To get started with Heritage free appraisals, fill out the online appraisal form, and attach pictures of your coins if you have them. If you are interested in professional appraisal services, you can contact one of Heritage's appraisal experts directly via email or phone. You can find the contact information for the experts on the company's professional appraisal page.

Best Free Coin Appraisal: Appraise My Coins

AppraiseMyCoins.com

AppraiseMyCoins.com

Why We Chose It: Appraise My Coins is a free online appraisal service that helps users organize and value their coin collections.

Pros
  • Easily look up coin values with online tool

  • Free appraisal submissions online

  • Founder is member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA) board

Cons
  • Only available for U.S. coins and bullion

  • Personal appraisals don’t allow picture attachment

  • Formal appraisals only available via parent company

Founded by Dr. Michael S. Fey, a board member of the ANA and coin collection consultant since 2000, Appraise My Coins is a free online appraisal website that helps users value their coins using its custom valuation tool. Dr. Fey is also the founder of Rare Coin Investments (RCI), and he offers coin collection advice and formal appraisals.

Appraise My Coins offers instant appraisals for users by helping guide them through identifying their exact coin, as well as the condition of that coin. Users can find U.S. minted coins, U.S. commemorative coins, U.S. coin sets, or precious metal coins for evaluation. 

While the free appraisal tool is for valuation purposes only, Dr. Fey offers formal appraisal services through his RCI Coin website with a fee of $50 an hour.

To get started with your free U.S. coin or bullion appraisal, you can view its online tool and find your specific coins for valuation.

Best for U.S. Coins: PGS Gold and Coin

PGS Gold & Coin

PGS Gold & Coin

Why We Chose It: PGS Gold and Coin specializes in evaluating and selling U.S. coins and bullion. Its detailed appraisal process helps users sort and submit their collections for appraisal.

Pros
  • Over 35 years of numismatic experience on staff

  • Certified coin-grading and appraisal experts

  • Detailed appraisals for U.S. coins

Cons
  • Formal appraisal starts at $175

  • Most appraisals are in-person at Illinois locations

PGS Gold and Coin is an Illinois-based dealer that focuses on gold and U.S. minted coins. Founded in 2008, it is a family-owned business and authorized coin dealer endorsed by organizations like PCGS and NGC.

The company offers in-person or remote appraisals of U.S. coins and can even professionally grade and authenticate your coins. The appraisals fall into two categories:

  • Verbal appraisals for valuation purposes
  • Formal written appraisals for legal and insurance purposes

The verbal appraisals cost $75 and can help value your coins or collection for consignment or auction sales. The written appraisals cost $175 per hour (minimum $175 charge) and are professionally reviewed by multiple appraisers. The written appraisals are used for estate valuations, legal proceedings, or for insurance purposes.

To get started with PGS Gold and Coin appraisals, you can view the company's guide to organizing your collection before submitting. Once your collection is arranged, you can contact the team via email, phone, or by submitting an online form.

Best for World Coins: Great Collections

Great Collections

Great Collections

Why We Chose It: Great Collections offers free online appraisals on world coins with pre-built excel spreadsheets for helping collectors organize their coins.

Pros
  • Certified numismatic experts on staff

  • Appraisals are free of charge

  • Over 900,000 coins sold from all over the world

Cons
  • Appraisals can’t be used for legal or insurance needs

  • Appraisals only available for auctionable coins

Great Collections is an online auction house that specializes in U. S. and world coin collections. Founded in 2010 by Ian Russell, the website has listed and sold over $400 million worth of rare coins online. 

The Great Collections staff is composed of domestic and world coin numismatic experts certified by several professional coin organizations, including Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and the Professional Numismatic Guild (PNG). The entire 11-year history of its auction sales is also available on its site, helping users evaluate and pre-appraise their collections using real-world sales prices.

Great Collections offers free appraisals for items that collectors are considering listing for sale. Clients can submit their coin details online and organize their collection using the Great Collection free excel spreadsheet.

To get a free appraisal from Great Collections, simply fill out the online form (and attach pictures if needed). If you have any questions, you can reach the Great Collections team via email or phone.

Final Verdict

If you are looking to sell your collection, finding a quality auction house to appraise and list your coins will help make the process simpler. For insurance or legal needs, always look for a professional certified by an organization like the American Numismatic Association (ANA) or Professional Numismatic Guild (PNG). These written appraisals will be considered valid in a court of law. Heritage Auctions Coins earned best overall on our list for its variety of appraisal and auction services, as well as its longstanding history handling U.S., world, and rare coins.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I Get My Coins Professionally Graded?

Most serious coin collectors and auction houses recommend getting rare and valuable coins professionally graded. This helps certify their authenticity, as well as their condition, and may help increase the value of your collection.

There are two main certification companies for coins:

How Much Does It Cost to Get a Coin Collection Appraised?

The costs associated with appraising your coin collection can vary depending on the type of appraisal needed. Many online appraisals are available for free, especially by auction houses looking to list your coins. These free appraisals are for valuation and selling purposes only.

Formal written appraisals can range from $75 to over $150 per hour, depending on the coins, appraisal details, and purpose. Formal written appraisals are typically used for insurance or legal purposes, such as estate planning.

Methodology

We reviewed the service offerings, prices, customer service, and expertise of almost a dozen appraisers from around the U.S. All appraisers on our list are numismatic experts with many decades of experience in the coin collection industry.