The 1933 Saint-Gaudens Gold Double Eagle

1933 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle - $20 U.S. Gold Coin

Wikimedia Commons

The U.S. 1933 $20 Saint-Gaudens Gold Double Eagles are coins of mystery and intrigue. They were never officially released by the United States Mint and all of them were supposedly melted. However, a few of them escaped the mint and were circulating in the underground rare coin market. The government confiscated several of them, and only one is legal to own.

The 1933 Gold Double Eagle was Never Officially Issued

The U.S. $20 Gold Double Eagle, Saint-Gaudens type, had been issued from 1907 until 1932. Although 445,500 Double Eagles had been minted with the 1933 date, not one was released into circulation because of changes made to currency laws during the Great Depression.

To end the run on the banks and stabilize the economy, President Franklin Roosevelt took America off the gold standard. Not only were no more gold coins to be issued for circulation, but people also had to turn in the ones they had. An executive order required all U.S. citizens to return their gold coins to the bank and exchange them for paper money. Although this was frowned upon by United States citizens, the penalties were steep and most citizens surrendered their coins for paper money.

The 1933 Double Eagles are Ordered to be Destroyed

It became illegal for private citizens to own gold coins unless they clearly had a collectible value. This law was enacted during desperate times to prevent the hoarding of gold currency. Since there would be no more gold currency issued in the U.S., the Mint had melted down the 1933 run of Gold Double Eagles and converted them to gold bullion bars by 1937.

Some of the Double Eagles Escaped the Melt Down

The Mint gave two of the 1933 specimens to the U.S. National Numismatic Collection at the Smithsonian Institute. These were the only two legal specimens ever to become part of a coin collection. However, by 1952, the Secret Service had confiscated eight more 1933 Double Eagles! How did they leave the Mint? Why weren't they melted down?

Was the 1933 Double Eagle Switched for Another Coin?

We may never know for sure how these coins left the Mint, but there is a general consensus among scholars that a Mint cashier by the name of George McCann exchanged about 20 1933's doomed for destruction and replaced them with earlier dated Double Eagles. This way, the accounting books would balance, and nobody would realize that anything was amiss.

What we do know for sure is that a Philadelphia area jeweler by the name of Israel Switt came into possession of at least 19 of the coins. Although, the Secret Service was aware of these coins circulating in the underground rare coin market, was difficult for them to track them down and confiscate them.

The Coin of a King

Israel Switt sold at least nine of the 1933 Double Eagles privately to collectors, one of which found its way into the collection of King Farouk of Egypt. When the Secret Service discovered that these coins had surfaced, they confiscated all of them because they were considered to be stolen property of the U.S. Mint. However, King Farouk had legally exported his coin before the theft was discovered, and the Secret Service was unable to recover his specimen through diplomatic channels.

The King's Specimen is Recovered in a Sting Operation

After King Farouk was deposed in 1952, his 1933 Double Eagle briefly appeared on the market, but when it became clear that U.S. authorities still wanted to confiscate it, it vanished again! More than 40 years later, British coin dealer Stephen Fenton showed up with it in New York, and the Secret Service finally seized it during a sting operation during which they purportedly negotiated to purchase the coin.

Terrorists Nearly destroy the 1933 Double Eagle

Fenton fought a several-year-long legal battle in the U.S. courts over ownership of the coin, during which time which it was stored in the Treasury Vaults at the World Trade Center. A mere two months before the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, the lawsuit was settled, and the Double Eagle was moved to Fort Knox. Fenton and the U.S. Mint had come to a compromise: the coin would be sold at auction, with the proceeds split between the Fenton and the Mint.

Legal Tender at Last - and the Most Valuable Coin in the World

The 1933 Double Eagle sold at auction on July 30, 2002, for $6.6 million, plus the 15% buyer's fee, which brought the total cost to the buyer to $7,590,000, plus $20 to monetize the coin and compensate the Mint for the $20 it believes it lost when the coin was thought to have been stolen. At that time this was a world record for purchasing a single coin.

The buyer chose to remain anonymous, and it is currently on display at The New-York Historical Society and Library, on temporary loan from an anonymous private collection. One thing is for sure: the Secret Service can't confiscate it anymore!

Ten More Specimens

In September of 2004, Joan Langbord, one of Israel Switt's heirs, discovered ten more specimens of the 1933 Double Eagle amongst his effects. Unaware of the legal status of these coins (or perhaps just a bit too trusting of the government) she sent all ten specimens to the U.S. Mint to have them authenticated. The Secret Service declared the coins genuine and seized them. This began a decade's protracted legal fight between the government and the Langbord.

A lower court ruled that the coins were the property of the United States government and therefore considered stolen property. Langbord appealed the ruling several times all the way up to the United States Supreme Court. In April 2017, the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case which ended the legal battle and left the ten 1933 Double Eagles in the custody of the government.

The Eleventh Coin Surrendered

On May 10, 2018, Greg Weinman, the U.S. Mint’s senior legal counsel, stated during a presentation at the Pennsylvania Association of Numismatists spring coin show that the government is aware of another example. Several weeks later the mint acknowledged that an anonymous collector surrendered the coin. It joined the other ten specimens under the care and protection of Fort Knox.

Is the 1933 Double Eagle Still the World's Most Valuable Coin?

It will be interesting to see, should the 10 Langbord coins ever come to market, if the 1933 Double Eagle will retain its place as the world's highest priced coin when the number of available specimens increases ten-fold. 

On January 24, 2013, Stacks Bowers Gallery sold a 1794 Flowing Hair silver dollar for over $10 million ($10,016,875 including the buyer's fee). On May 24, 2016 Stacks Bowers Gallery attempted to sell the finest known 1804 silver dollar from the D. Brent Pogue collection. However, the coin failed to reach the secret reserve amount and did not sell.

Another competitor for the world's most expensive coin may be the 1822 half eagle ten dollar gold coin. This coin his unique and has only been in three collections in the last 115 years. In October 1982, D. Brent Pogue purchased the coin for $687,500. In May 2016, Stack's/Bowers and Sotheby's Auctions offered the coin where a bid of $6,400,000 failed to satisfy the hidden reserve.

Edited by: James Bucki